Letters to the Editor

Anonymous, via email

There are so many ahadiths, of which some are sahih. Does it mean there are non-Sahih ahadith also? Please clarify.

YMD

Yes, there are inauthentic traditions of the Prophet but they have been separated out and are not contained in the Sihah Sittah (the six canonical collections). There are other smaller compilations that carry only the trustworthy reports. Inauthentic ahadith are normally found in magazines, newspapers, speeches, or oral transmissions. You should therefore, never accept any hadith coming from these sources. When you find them written, do not read. Just wave them away when they happen to come to notice. Take the hadith either from the Sihah works, or from books that are written by well-known scholars. Seek a proper scholar’s help in choosing a book.

Is there anyone who can be online in order to help me out of some religious dilemmas?

YMD

Sorry, we lack the means to offer such services.

About YMD
Subscribe
Donate

Past Issues