Letters to the Editor

Q. Hats off to you Mr. Editor…

YMD

Since the metaphor, translated into Islamic culture, would have entirely the opposite significance you could say,  “caps on,” instead of “hats off.” Isn’t it interesting how the two cultures, one of hats, and the other of caps, stand at 180o to each other?!

Q. …For you seem to have developed expertise in giving an ambiguous essence to the flavour of your answers.

YMD

A thin line, visible to an expert eye, separates subtlety from ambiguity.

Q. You say that TV is itself prohibited in Islam which is absolutely correct, going by the fact that picture concept is totally illegal for entertainment purpose, except in case of extreme inevitability for e.g. photos for passport, ration card, license etc.

YMD

But in our opinion it is not legitimate to demand photos from the ration cardholder, considering the fact that 80% of Indians have to sell their share of rice to get themselves photographed for their ration cards. What’s your opinion?

Q.  Then you elaborate further that we can make a generalized and unconditional statement that TV is illegal. 

YMD

Generalized statements take the responsibility off the adviser and load it on to the shoulders of those who have to deal with specific situations. That’s where the test of integrity comes.

Q. And then you advertise the latest model of the most popular brand of TV on the colorful attractive cover page of your magazine. 

YMD

We are sure the product advertiser will be pleased with the adjectives you have used, and – hopefully – will repeat his advertisement

Q. And if somebody asks you to clarify, you say that you are advertising an instrument.

YMD

That is because you see, anything that has several components put together, and offers a certain function, whether mechanical, electrical, or visual is referred to as an instrument in the English language. If in doubt, consult nearest professor in English.

Q. What the hell should we do with the TV instrument without being able to watch the programs?

YMD

If you have already bought one, you could keep a flowerpot over it. We have seen the instrument put to such uses in many homes.

Q. Just take a census if you have enough guts and find out how many people want to buy the TV just to keep it for the sake of home decoration.  

YMD

Our problem is time and not guts, so, you might have to excuse us.

Q. I can assure you that 99% would detest the idea.

YMD

We feel assured.

Q. 1% of the TV program consists of the live telecast of Tarawih prayers during the month Ramadan, the telecast of Hajj pilgrimage etc.

YMD

A very impressive sight they are, we are told.

Q. Now, it is not even Mustahab to watch the Tarawih or Hajj telecast.  Whereas, it is Haram to watch other 99% programs.

YMD

We cannot vouchsafe to the Fatwa about the 99%.

Q. So, Mr. Intelligent editor and money-hungry publisher, you want us to believe in your stupid concept.  Sheer baloney.

YMD

Perhaps you need to make up your mind about what we are, and then speak up with greater certainty.

Q. So in the end you want to say “buy the TV and keep it shut for complete eleven months.”

YMD

And save electrical power. Many industries cannot run to full capacity in India because of severe shortage of power.

Q. Mr. Editor/ Publisher, you are not even good a businessman.

YMD

Several people have told us that. We don’t understand what gives them the idea that we are in business.

Q. The first thing you should do now is to render an unconditional apology in your immediate next issue.

YMD

If some of our readers do not like these lines, we apologize to them.

Q. I was the only one to subscribe for YMD in 1998. Now I have convinced my five friends to subscribe for it and they have obliged. But now I have to answer them and I need your assistance and I hope you will not let me down.

Mohammed Abrar Parvez 
On Email

YMD

We will never let you down. We are firmly with you in your concern and advise that the TV may not be purchased if there is no control over what a family can watch, and what it may not.

As regards promoting the readership of YMD, yes, you should advise your friends to continue reading it. It might take them time to learn something from it, (for e.g., manners) but ultimately it is expected they will profit from it.

About YMD
Subscribe
Donate

Past Issues